તમે તૈયાર થઈ રહેલી WORLD360ની ગુજરાતી આવૃત્તિ વાંચી રહ્યા છો. મેનુ અને શીર્ષકો ગુજરાતીમાં છે; અનુવાદ તૈયાર ન થાય ત્યાં સુધી સમાચાર અંગ્રેજીમાં દેખાશે.

Judiciary

7-judge SC bench may defer ruling on free speech vs legislative privilege battle

The Supreme Court may put off a landmark case on free speech after learning the 20-year-old resolution that sparked it was withdrawn long ago.

◆2 સ્વતંત્ર સ્રોત◆8 સ્રોત સામગ્રી◆heat 0.03◆અપડેટ: 5m

Outlets are counted by registrable domain, so a broadcaster’s station subdomains count once. 6 of the 8 items repeat an outlet already counted.

એન્જિનનું આકલન10.6% overlap with its sources

The Supreme Court may put off a landmark case on free speech after learning the 20-year-old resolution that sparked it was withdrawn long ago.

Why the Hearing Was Paused

A seven-judge Supreme Court bench is poised to defer a major hearing on whether legislative privilege can override freedom of speech. The case originated with a 2003 Tamil Nadu Assembly resolution to arrest editors of The Hindu newspaper for an editorial critical of the chief minister.

On Monday, a lawyer for the Tamil Nadu Assembly informed a bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant that the resolution was withdrawn in 2004. According to The Hindu, the lawyer, Raju Ramachandran, noted this fact was not mentioned in the court's order that sent the case to the large bench.

Avoiding an Academic Debate

Chief Justice Kant stated the court preferred not to engage in an "academic exercise" if the original dispute was no longer active, especially with other matters pending. Ramachandran argued that since the resolution was gone, hearing the case would be purely academic.

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, representing the petitioners, agreed that the specific Tamil Nadu issue was likely "dead." He maintained, however, that the broader constitutional question of legislative privilege versus free speech remains highly relevant.

Both Sibal and India's Solicitor General, Tushar Mehta, supported the Chief Justice's suggestion to wait for a more suitable case to settle the question, the Hindustan Times reported.

What Happens Next

The Chief Justice proposed that the court could keep the case formally open and address the legal questions when another live controversy arises in the future.

The seven-judge bench is still expected to convene on Tuesday. However, it will likely only review the new information about the withdrawn resolution before formally closing the current proceedings.

Coverage

2 independent outlets filed 6 reports over 2 days. Coverage has been thinning.

2outlets
6filings
54hspan
fadingtrend
What could happen next
No outcome sealed yet.the engine has not sealed a forecast on this story yet. The forecast is always written to the ledger before any article about it, never the other way round.
પુરાવા8 items
Supreme Court seeks review of State DGP appointment rules against 2006 Prakash Singh judgment

The 2006 judgment referred to by a Bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant had laid down guidelines for transparent appointment process and a minimum tenure of two years

CEC, ECs appointment law: SC soon to take decision on listing of plea to recall order

Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant on Wednesday said that a decision will soon be taken on listing the application seeking recall of an order referring the challenge to the law governing the appointment of the chief election commissioner and election commissioners to a Constitution bench

Supreme Court to hear Centre’s contempt plea against appointment of Jharkhand DGP Tadasha Mishra

A Bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana was urged by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta that the contempt plea be also listed for hearing

CJI Surya Kant says SC will soon decide on plea to recall CEC law order

CJI Surya Kant said the Supreme Court will soon decide on a plea seeking recall of its order referring the challenge to the CEC appointment law to a Constitution bench.

Privilege versus free speech case in Supreme Court disposed of in half an hour after two-decade wait

Supreme Court quickly disposes a 20-year privilege vs. free speech case after the Tamil Nadu Assembly resolution was withdrawn

Legislative privilege versus free speech: SC may not hear on merits after TN Assembly says resolution was withdrawn

The development comes after senior advocate Raju Ramachandran, appearing for the Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly, made an oral mentioning before a Bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant that the 2003 resolution was withdrawn the following year

7-judge SC bench may defer ruling on free speech vs legislative privilege battle

Attorney general R Venkataramani and solicitor general Tushar Mehta, who were also present, agreed that the issue may now have become academic.

Sources are evidence, not content. Each keeps its own name, its own link and an extract capped at 400 characters; none of it is rewritten into the copy above.

ભારતમાં વધુ
1/8All →