Apple says AI agents make broad file access riskier, after a columnist said Meta's Muse read his messages without his permission — a claim Meta disputes.
What Apple is changing
Apple said Friday it will add new controls around Full Disk Access, a macOS permission that gives an app access to a user's entire system. Apple described the setting as one that largely skips past the privacy controls users otherwise have, and said it exists so that backup apps can work properly on a Mac.
In a blog post aimed at developers, Apple said some developers are using Full Disk Access in ways that could put users at risk, exposing files, mail, messages and browsing history without users' full knowledge and understanding. For communication apps, Apple added, that access can also compromise the privacy of the people a user communicates with.
Going forward, Apple said users who genuinely want to give an app that level of access should be able to do so only through what it called very explicit user action. Apple did not say when the change will roll out, did not respond to TechCrunch's inquiry about it, and did not immediately respond to The Verge's request for comment. TechCrunch reported that the decision also followed a Wired report about a flaw in ChatGPT's Mac app that could have let hackers reach sensitive data.
The messages behind the change
The announcement followed a report by Inc. columnist Jason Aten, who said Meta's new AI agent Muse sent him an unsolicited notification referring to a thread between him and a co-worker on Apple Messages. He said he never gave Muse permission to read his messages and had assumed they were off-limits.
Meta disputed that account. Ars Technica reported that Meta CTO David Singleton said the Messages integration is opt-in, and that Muse can read Messages content only if a user grants macOS Full Disk Access and also enables a Messages connector inside Muse. The Verge reported that Meta spokesperson Andy Stone made the same argument, calling access entirely opt-in.
Ars Technica reported that macOS security expert Patrick Wardle questioned that defense, saying that with full disk access any non-root file is readable, including browsing history, browser cookies and chats. When Ars asked Meta how Muse could fail to read messages while holding a permission that lets other apps do so, the company's press team repeated Singleton's statement, the outlet said. Ars also noted that social media users compared AI assistants with broad access to power tools — useful, but capable of real damage if handled carelessly.
How the outlets describe it
The filings disagree on what kind of change this is. TechCrunch published a correction saying it had described Apple as limiting permissions, and the author updated the wording to say the change is about informed consent rather than a new limit. The Verge reported that Apple will add new limits to full disk access, while Ars Technica wrote that Apple is changing its macOS privacy settings to stop developers from misusing them.
They also date the gap differently: TechCrunch said the announcement came days after Aten's claim, Ars Technica said two weeks after, and The Verge said just weeks after. None of the filings says when Apple will release the change.
Coverage
3 independent outlets filed 3 reports over 5 hours.
3outlets
3filings
5hspan
singletrend
What could happen next
No outcome sealed yet.the engine has not sealed a forecast on this story yet. The forecast is always written to the ledger before any article about it, never the other way round.