Judiciary

‘Cannot offer tax cuts to same-sex couples’: Centre tells Karnataka High Court

The Centre told Karnataka’s High Court that extending gift‑tax exemptions to same‑sex couples would amount to legally recognising a marriage the law does not currently acknowledge.

◆2 independent outlets◆4 source items◆heat 0.06◆updated 27m

Outlets are counted by registrable domain, so a broadcaster’s station subdomains count once. 2 of the 4 items repeat an outlet already counted.

The engine’s read14.2% overlap with its sources

The Centre told Karnataka’s High Court that extending gift‑tax exemptions to same‑sex couples would amount to legally recognising a marriage the law does not currently acknowledge.

Centre rejects same‑sex tax claim

The Union government appeared before a Karnataka High Court bench on Monday to oppose a petition by a same‑sex couple seeking a gift‑tax exemption normally available to married spouses. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and Additional Solicitor General Arvind Kamath argued that the plaintiffs cannot rely on the Income Tax Act to obtain a benefit tied to a marital status that Indian law does not recognise.

Legal basis for denial

The government said the tax provision refers only to relationships recognised by law, and that redefining “spouse” to include same‑sex partners would implicitly recognise same‑sex marriage. It added that such an interpretation could open avenues for tax evasion, so the exemption should remain limited to legally married couples.

Petitioners' challenge

The petitioners, Anurag Kalia and Akhilesh Godi, contend that denying them the exemption amounts to unequal treatment, as married couples can exchange gifts without tax. Their counsel highlighted that a 22‑karat gold bracelet—a family heirloom—had been gifted and that the current law forces same‑sex partners to pay tax for expressing their love.

Coverage

2 independent outlets filed 4 reports over 22 hours. The filing rate has held steady.

2outlets
4filings
22hspan
steadytrend
What could happen next
No outcome sealed yet.the engine has not sealed a forecast on this story yet. The forecast is always written to the ledger before any article about it, never the other way round.
The evidence4 items
‘Cannot offer tax cuts to same-sex couples’: Centre tells Karnataka High Court

The government made the submissions before a bench of Justice B Shyama Prasad on Monday while opposing a plea filed by a same-sex couple.

Patna High Court acquits 13 accused in 1996 Jehanabad quadruple murder case

A Division Bench comprising Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad and Justice Kumar Manish delivered the ruling, citing grave lapses in the police investigation

Investigation reveals collection of ‘party fund’ during Anbil Mahesh Poyyamozhi’s tenure as School Education Minister, CCB tells Madras High Court

It makes the submission in a counter affidavit filed before Justice V. Lakshminarayanan in response to the former Minister’s plea to quash the FIR against him

Reservation cannot be proportionate to population of castes, says Karnataka High Court

Accepting population as the basis for reservation would be ‘destructive of the principle of equality’, the court says

Sources are evidence, not content. Each keeps its own name, its own link and an extract capped at 400 characters; none of it is rewritten into the copy above.

More from India
1/8All →